Accepting a miniature wooden canoe from an old man
of the Tao tribe, Premier Yu Shyi-kun promised to
establish a new partnership with the indigenous people
of Orchid Island, which is known as "Lanyu" in Chinese,
off the southeastern coast of Taiwan. Yu was not there
for pleasure, but to apologize for the government's
failure to remove the nuclear waste that has been
stored on the Tao homeland for the past two decades.
Following Economics Minister Lin Yi-fu's visit to
Orchid Island early this month, Yu made the trip himself
as a further assurance to residents that the current
administration will correct past wrongs and try to
realize the goal of a nuclear-free nation.
"I apologize for what the government has done to the
Tao people," the premier said last week. He stressed
that the administration's nuclear-free ideal has not
changed and that it will begin by removing the radioactive
waste from Lanyu.
He told residents of the tiny island that the Cabinet
will come up with a proposal in three months. In the
meantime it will take measures to improve the standard
of living, education and medical services available
on the island. Finding a new storage site remains
a thorny issue, especially since the premier has promised
to obtain the consent of local residents of any future
site for storage of the radioactive waste.
About 45 square kilometers in area, Orchid Island
is under the administrative jurisdiction of the Taitung
County Government. It is currently home to approximately
3,200 members of the Tao tribe, which has come to
be symbolized by the wooden canoe with red trim traditionally
built by tribesmen. The Tao, once called Yami, are
unique among Taiwan's recognized tribes in that they
never practiced headhunting or fermented alcohol.
In fact, they have more in common from an anthropological
perspective with the Batan islanders of the northern
Philippines.
The Atomic Energy Council began shipping low-grade
radioactive waste produced in Taiwan's three nuclear
plants, hospitals and research facilities to Orchid
Island in 1982. In 1990, state-run Taiwan Power Co.--the
agency responsible for energy production on the island--took
over management of the repository, which now holds
an estimated 98,000 barrels of nuclear waste. The
power company has since provided free electricity
to households on Orchid Island and contributed to
infrastructure development.
The aboriginal community, however, claimed that authorities
failed to reveal to them the real purpose for building
the repository back in the late 1970s, leading them
to believe that the site was to be a can factory.
It was not until 1988 that local residents began staging
mass protests against further shipments of nuclear
waste, which they refer to as anito, or "malevolent
spirit." Tribal leaders believe that radiation from
the nuclear dump is behind the island's rising rates
of cancer and mental retardation. They have accused
the government of trampling their human rights and
demanded immediate removal of the radioactive waste.
They said that about 30,000 barrels show signs of
rusting out and could be the source of possible radiation.
Taipower's failure to honor a pledge made several
years ago to ship the waste off the island by 2002
again roused indignation in the Tao community. They
held out hope that the present administration led
by the Democratic Progressive Party would be different,
especially since President Chen Shui-bian vowed to
form a partnership with the indigenous people while
on the campaign trail and again just a few months
after his May 2000 inauguration. The Tao people thus
launched another large-scale protest recently, prompted
public apologies from the economics minister and now
the premier.
When Lin visited Orchid Island May 4, he signed an
agreement with the Tao tribe to the effect that the
government would undertake to protect the rights of
the indigenous people. "We will push for legislation
to guarantee the nature rights and living rights of
the Tao tribe," Lin said.
The minister later announced that two commissions
have already been set up to address the issues of
dumpsite relocation and development plans for local
communities. The relocation commission, Lin noted,
is composed of environmentalists, academics and officials
as well as representatives of the Tao tribe and officers
of Taipower.
The agreement also stipulated that the government
be held responsible for any consequences resulting
from its failure to abide by the provisions.
Over the years, the government has made a fruitless
attempt to find alternate storage sites for nuclear
waste. Negotiations have been conducted with such
countries as North Korea, Russia, the Marshall Islands
and the PRC, but to no avail. World opinion arrays
itself against Taiwan whenever it floats the idea
of shipping nuclear waste overseas.
There have been proposals to ship the hazardous substance
to one of Taiwan's scarcely populated islets for storage.
Although Taipower officials maintain that they have
not ruled out any possibilities at home and abroad,
they admitted that an environmental impact assessment
is currently underway on Hsiaochiu, an islet of Wuchiu,
which lies about 70 nautical miles off Kinmen Island
in the Taiwan Strait.
Taipower stressed that it is still too early to arrive
at any decision, as the company still needs to consult
Wuchiu's approximately four dozen residents. Even
if they consent to the storage, the construction of
dock facilities and repository could take up to 10
years, said company officials.
There are currently three nuclear power plants in
Taiwan: two in the Northeast and one in the South.
Taipower's proposal in 1980 to build a fourth one
in Taipei County drew severe criticism from local
residents and environmentalists alike. The DPP, then
an opposition party, also fiercely opposed the project.
The controversy gathered steam for over a decade until
construction began in 1998 despite ongoing protest.
The difficulties involved in the disposal of nuclear
waste was one of the main reasons former Premier Chang
Chun-hsiung halted construction of the fourth nuclear
power plant in late 2000. Describing the energy byproduct
as "a perennial pain in the neck," Chang said that
the government would instead develop renewable sources
of energy.
Chang's move later triggered a political firestorm
for the Chen administration. Legislators threatened
to recall the president and initiate a no-confidence
vote against the premier, saying that because the
budget for the partially completed power plant had
been passed by the Legislature, the Cabinet's move
was illegal.
Construction of the plant resumed in 2001 after the
Judicial Yuan ruled that the Cabinet had made a procedural
flaw in halting construction. But officials said a
nuclear-free home remains the ultimate goal of the
Chen administration, whose policy priorities include
building a greener Taiwan. So far hydropower, coal
and liquefied natural gas provide over 80 percent
of energy consumed on the island. The government is
also exploring renewable energy resources such as
solar power and wind generators.
Even so, as consumption rises and the public expects
more energy to be churned out by the new nuclear plant,
radioactive waste will remain a problem that the authorities
must take seriously.